
Sword Art Online continues to surprise as it brings its first two-part episode to a satisfactory close – however in doing so, the below average series successfully further hurls itself into the category of “sub-par”.
For once, things pick up exactly where they left off – the bishoujo introduced last episode, who was trying to find the one responsible for the murder of the leader of her guild, the “Golden Apple”, instead finds herself literally stabbed in the back from a knife which came flying through a window behind her, resulting in her “death” within a safe zone of this unartistic sword place. Assuming the obvious, Kirito pursues a cloaked fellow, and presumed assassin – only for them to escape via a teleportaion crystal.
It is revealed this would-be assassin looks exactly the same as Griselda, the expired leader of “Golden Apple” – and her last remaining subordinate deems the assassin the “ghost” of the former leader.
Later that evening, Kirito’s apparent weakness for the opposite sex aids him in unraveling the true nature to this murder case. After dropping his one of a kind, past due date, heroine-made sandwich, the fall forcibly causes the item itself to “expire” – subsequently inciting a spectacular revelation in which the leading male realizes a basic element of this RPG game, showing that even overpowered “master of everything” protagonists will be susceptible to simple knowledge when the lack of plot calls for it.
He reaches the conclusion that none were murdered by the ghost of Griselda at all – yet instead, they forcibly destroyed their armour, causing it to expire at the same time as they teleported to safety. This means that everything which happened up until now was a ploy amongst the guild members to catch the real culprit – not to mention, another pointless escapade on the list.
Seeing that it’s no longer his business, as if it ever was to begin with, Kirito decides that he has already played his part in the case, assuming he had one – and now merely lets the other guild members clean up their own mess.
Meanwhile, as a means to repent in some way for the wrongs he committed, the forgettable side-character from last episode, the hulking brute from before who was whaling like a little kid, begs for forgiveness at Griselda’s grave – only to find himself confessing to his two former allies disguising as ghosts that he was assisting an anonymous guild member to gain a rare item, Griselda’s ring. All of his confession goes recorded by the generic blue-haired bishoujo from before – likely to be used as a means to send him to jail.
Afterwards, out of nowhere, the remaining members of “Golden Apple” are ambushed by a another group of worthless irrelevant canon – a guild of PK’ers known as the “Laughing Coffin”, their name perhaps being the most elaborate aspect of this plot twist. The crew of expendable characters were hired by the real culprit to dispose of all evidence relating to his thievery of the ring, as well as the murder of Griselda – and said culprit turns out to be her actual and digital husband, Grimelocke, a twist immensely shocking in how blatantly unoriginal it is.
Topping off the banality, Kirito comes to the rescue – scaring everyone away with his main character status, and being dubbed the hero despite his lack of basic game understanding.
If this were a mystery series, this could be considered somewhat an interesting episode – yet the story of the murder of some worthless side-character only further serves to stall what is a below average anime with tattered rags for plot. Instead of utilizing this episode to focus more on Kirito and Asuna, Sword Art Online expertly made use of its first two-part segment for the most story irrelevant episode yet – emphasizing the main characters only when it comes time to frighten all the terrible bad guys away,
One can assume that by next episode, likely to be set several weeks or months in the future, we will be introduced to more new characters ready to be killed off within the same episode – dying alongside the quality of the series.


























Aug 11, 2012 @ 23:33 CDT
Gee, I wonder if they’re gonna get married, it’s not like they’re making super obvious or something.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 2:19 CDT
actually next episode will start to pick up the plot with Kirito going after a new sword (if they are following the timeline for the side stories). After that episode is over there won’t be another side story for a few episodes (maybe 3 or 4)
Aug 12, 2012 @ 4:53 CDT
I’ve been hearing people say “next episode will start to pick up” after every episode.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 5:26 CDT
“actually next episode will start to pick up the plot with Kirito going after a new sword (if they are following the timeline for the side stories)”
Wow, Kirito utilizes the fundamental elements of an RPG? Will it be introduced like every other new episode? – “”3 months later”, Here we are! The dungeon of blahblah!”.
“After that episode is over there won’t be another side story for a few episodes (maybe 3 or 4)”
… “for a few episodes”. This is exactly the point, there is too much side to this story that is making it feel like the every day virtual life of Kirito and Asuna, except replace “every day” with “harshly summarised”. This anime needs to pick up on the action, and provide an advancement to the currently on hiatus story, which I hardly see it keeping up.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 2:32 CDT
I can’t say I like where the thing is going, absolutely nowhere. But it’s better than going backwards I guess…
But all in all this episode was pretty disappointing, I mean even with 2 episodes under the same…Sidestory? it could’ve easily spent another one adding in the bits and pieces instead of just taking out chunks and making the story incoherent with just gaps all over the place,
With 10 volumes under the same name there’s definitely enough plot for that to go on with, but it seems that all recent anime must take a break from the “main plot” every time I turn the lights off in the kitchen or something. And they just tear things apart whenever they feel like it.
How in the hell did the realization that he never loved his wife as a person, but as a possesion become enough for him to just collapse like that? This is someone who killed and manipulated people, but due to time restrictions and budgeting and most likely the director having the memory of a goldfish, they just make most characters either completely feeble or have as much personality as the other goldfish in the bowl.
I don’t know, maybe it’s because it’s been a while since I saw something with a good plot, or maybe there’s some kind of Anime Writers Association Union thing that has to make every single story ever made have a these kinds of things over and over again. Maybe it’s like Net Neutrality where people decided that every anime should either be 12-13 eps or 22-25 and must contain MOE of some sorts.
And also
http://imgur.com/JWgRq
What? O__o
Aug 12, 2012 @ 5:31 CDT
We share the same thoughts. It’s sad, but probably true.
Also I guess for Kirito fans out there, they’ll glee that he’s a virgin? xD
Aug 12, 2012 @ 2:49 CDT
I seem to be having mixed feeling about this series now that it’s clear that i’m completely confused as to where this series seems to be going. Looking at this episode i must say that this was better than the last episode but again we see no action just the continuation of the side story plot which leads to ..well..nothing as such. The positive thing here is the budding relationship between Asuna and Kirito . Its high time the series just went to the main plot already if they dont want the audience to grow tired and bored from the side stories ….
Aug 12, 2012 @ 4:50 CDT
The positive is that this useless two-parter is now over.
In the end, their relationship only really developed via a rather normal friend request.
However, I do also share feelings with you, the moment of an episode can be enjoyed briefly, but then you back out just a little bit, to see all the canyon sized cracks in this series. Since there are plentiful episodes left, SAO could do the dirty on our low expectations and make a 180 flip in the right direction. But that would be preposterous.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 4:03 CDT
A) Laughing Coffin is actually an incredibly important antagonist, perhaps the most important in the series.
B) The members of Laughing Coffin are skilled enough to kill Kirito (especially 3 on 1), which is why Kirito had to use the frankly stupid bluff that he had 30 other guys coming behind him.
C) I can completely understand why you missed this, because the anime completely failed to make them seem dangerous or important. Giving them all generic face covering cloaks certainly didn’t help.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 4:51 CDT
The anime completely fails at a lot of things.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 5:08 CDT
A) While that can be agreed, they poorly presented these “antagonists”. Ideally, the best way to introduce these characters is doing what they do best. But their efforts amount to no more than that of an anticlimatic brush in with Pokémon’s Team Rocket, only replace “blasting off again”, with simply walking away with that “I’ll be back!” feel.
B) If these guys are so important, why not cause deaths like all the other episodes seemed quite happy to deliver? Instead one of the party gets paralysed by a small dagger to the shoulder, “:O It’s the PK Guild… Laughing Coffin”. It’s as if you are saying the less action, and the less deaths there are in an episode, the more important to the “story” it actually is.
C) As much as I respect how you feel, viewers who are new to SAO such as myself and a hefty portion and it’s viewers, are left to pick up the pieces and attempt to take a tangible guess as to what is even relevant. Unfortunately, it’s down to commenters with an endearing passion to anti-bash this anime, to provide us that insight.
In short, that is production that has so far failed to connect, and properly tell it’s story with the viewers.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 15:51 CDT
Not really. it depends on how far this adaptation will be animated. If they’re not going beyond ALO, then fleshing them out is just stupid
Aug 12, 2012 @ 8:13 CDT
This series would have been a lot better if they just concentrated on Volume 1 material aka the main story of the SAO arc of SAO. A 12 episode adaptation (plus, chapter 16.5 as an OVA *wink*) would have been a lot better so that the plot will develop better.
Aug 13, 2012 @ 23:07 CDT
Or they should have just not animated it.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 10:09 CDT
I have to start wondering if this series is any good at all, light novel or otherwise:
http://i.imgur.com/WhAYH.jpg
Extra chapters are still chapters if they’re made by official hands.
Aug 12, 2012 @ 12:55 CDT
Now that’s just mean. :(
I have to admit, I never read that chapter because the whole idea seemed pretty stupid. In the context of the rest of the story, they just have sex offscreen and you think “aw, how sweet” and/or “huh, never expected a shounen anime to let the main couple have sex in volume 1″.
Luckily, that’s not really the point. The point is to have Kirito be needlessly badass in a surprisingly well-imagined fictional game world. All wish fulfillment, all the time.
Aug 15, 2012 @ 16:54 CDT
LOL is that seriously……? I never read that chapter and it was taken off of the wiki (being 18+ and all), but if that’s real it’s hilarious. Buahahahahahahahha
Aug 15, 2012 @ 20:56 CDT
“it’s hilarious.”
And so is the sheer lacking quality of Sword Art Online.