An elemental workshop.

Tasogare Otome Ends Worse Than It Began

Jun 25, 2012 @ 6:04 CDT


Tasogare Otome X Amnesia concludes as it began, with oppai fondling – the series ends certainly above average overall, and spectacular in visuals specifically, yet not nearly as strong in story and character.

Getting the aesthetics out of the way, they’re outstanding in every single way – Silver Link, the studio responsible for this respectable ghost tale, is by far the most talented in pure art at its finest. Their palette of hues is extensive – and their scheming with them is highly precise. They combine fantastic and unique colors alongside a book’s worth of varied art styles which range heavily – however, a more notable few would be watercolor themed or plain abstract.

The camera will be played with, patterns will be present, perspective is not forgotten – Silver Link utilizes a full toolkit as necessary to tell their story with the greatest extent of the effect desired, and much of this has been examined in the past. However, an issue arises in respect to storytelling – this is an area where Silver Link isn’t the best of the best, unlike their capabilities in aesthetics.

Silver Link has a history of struggling in telling even at least a decent story, if nothing more – meaning that in other words, they’ve a track record of terrible plot. This series differs in that while it first seems to be yet another slip and fall, one will notice that around half-way through, it suddenly turns spectacular as many aspects believed meaningless end up shining with significance – and this further stays critical as the story expands.

Indeed, this series actually becomes astounding past a certain point as Silver Link’s unprecedented artwork begins to relay a completely original story – succeeding in striking the nerves in many a way by subjecting our small cast to an assortment of unforeseen horror and dismay.

However, a flaw to tarnish that strong story they’ve managed to build exists in this very episode – leading up to the finale, many hints were made to imply that Yuuko will ultimately disappear, yet the problem is that she does not. Whilst Yuuko is enjoying time with her Teichi-kun, the episode further makes it clear that Yuuko will not last much longer – Teichi becomes aware of the fate awaiting his beloved ghost, and to no surprise, he breaks down as a response.

From there on, a bulk of the episode is spent on the expected whining and crying at having the only girl who lets him fondle her oppai disappear – yet Yuuko insists he get over it since it can’t be helped, though either way it’s clear she cares as well. In any case, Teichi convinces her to spend time with him till they’re pulled apart – and then nearing the end, the ghost finally disappears, leaving our protagonist to live a new life after the usual round of tears.

Now the major point of ruin for this series is that, one end sequence later, the ghost magically returns on the basis that she just conveniently turned out to have had more stuff to do in the worldly realm – thereby managing to stay manifested as a supernatural body on the face of the planet indefinitely, effectively making everything shown prior in this episode immensely pointless, and doing nothing with the strong foundation laid by the captivating developments of earlier episodes.

This series would still be considered certainly “above average” on a total scale – yet the finale unfortunately severs it from becoming a masterful series all-around, and in fact, keeps it from being anything worth watching. When a circular ending is all there is to look forward to – then indeed, that’s nothing to look forward to at all.

  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • RSS Feed
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter

13 Comments

  • eliscrubs says:

    Oh, Silver Link. All you had to do was end that episode 2 minutes earlier, and it would have been completely perfect. How they could do everything so incredibly well, and just screw it over for no reason, is beyond me. I hope they didn’t do it for a possible second season, because if they did…

    A moment of silence for Kirie, who took the biggest hit this series: being an awesome bishoujo, and getting ignored anyway.

    • Seven says:

      They could have have a great series if they just would have filled those two minutes with a regular black credits screen and some fancy music.

      And indeed, Kirie practically did everything meaningful.

  • alexsaingxd says:

    This series has been great – I was scared that Yuuko might have gone away forever. It was intense as well. But it was kind of ironic about why couldn’t she go to heaven though – because of this kiss that they had before she disappeared. What can we all say? True love last forever and ever.

  • I don’t think it undermines the overall journey, and I would say that it’s still a show well-worth watching. The disappearance was only mentioned at all at the end of Episode 11, and the rest of the show was building towards the understanding of her past, which was resolved. Episode 11 was the plot’s real resolution, and this was more of a coda. While there is a certain emotional satisfaction in a conclusive farewell, it may be a challenge when the manga is on-going and a 13th bonus episode is on its way in December. Indeed, there isn’t actually any rule that says Yuuko had to ascend at that time, but it seems she had simply made that assumption and thus resolved herself to it (not unlike how people saw what they believed in the earlier episodes). While I can certainly identify with the fact that some people may feel somewhat “trolled” by concluding episode, I don’t think saying it “keeps [the show] from being anything worth watching” is justifiable except in the most personal/subjective sense.

    • Seven says:

      Well, I don’t disagree – though I also don’t believe most people will want to start a series with a weak beginning, and tattered ending, only to enjoy the exquisite middle portion.

      • I didn’t find the beginning particularly weak, and I think you’re still overplaying how “tattered” the ending is. I think the love story conveyed through the show is the main feature, and is well-worth it for any fan of romantic anime.

        • alexsaingxd says:

          The series is already over though it was a good ending – it was ironic though, however, fans would want the ending to be in a different way. The best way to do that is to use their imagination. I wouldn’t mind the ending being changed as long it’s good. The beginning of course was weak though it had lots of comedy. Including the first two episodes (I think) where as it explains how it all happens – appearing Yuuko causing all of this (example – pushing Teichi in the elevator) while no one can see her. Overall, series was good though the beginning had a weak introduction – coming off to an intense feeling of emotions for an ending. Aside from this, if the beginning was strong and kept it strong until the end, i would want it to be as strong as Aquarion Evol, but in a romantic way for Amnesia series.

  • alan says:

    They used the worst excuse to bring her back, it would had been better for a transfer student that looked like her to end up in Teiichi’s class, actually anything would had been a better ending than the one they used. Also even though the end was similar to the one of Ano Hana i didn’t feel the need to let out a tear like i did with Ano Hana’ ending, that ending made me cry like a little baby.

  • Anonymous says:

    This was the best anime ever. I have never felt such emotion since the first time i saw elfen lied.
    The ending was very romantic and i am highly pleased with it. If Yuuko went to heaven and left Teiichi after all that it would have broken my heart. That’s too sad, and too like, common or cliché. The fact she came back because of her love for Teiichi was beautiful. Silver Link did an excellent job with this both visually and story-wise. By far the best anime i have ever seen with Elfen Lied. I needed something romantic like this. Thank you tremendously.

    • Seven says:

      I don’t totally agree with you – I believe some areas could have been better, but indeed, Silver Link truly abolished the standards of romance and supernatural with this animation, minus the excess abundance of oppai fondling.

Leave a Reply

Post a comment anonymously. Login, or register to post using your own name, avatar, and identity.

Your comment will appear shortly.

Article Comments Feed Random Post

In Other News...

  • Accel World – Now With 2 Flavors Of Chest
    One must wonder if Accel World’s entire raison d’être is simply for someone to profit off bikinis – as while the anime certainly isn’t even trying to be spectacular, mizugi artwork keeps coming at an unstoppable rate. ... read more
  • “Red Data Girl” Looks Dated In Style
    Official site of upcoming P.A. Works slice of life, “RDG Red Data Girl”, has renewed its official site – now offering a new key visual as well, albeit nothing too extraordinary in taste or style, an average illustration. ... read more
  • Aquarion EVOL Sci-Fi Sexual Excitement
    Sex powered mech anime Aquarion EVOL returns to once again somehow satisfy all which an otaku can ask for in a manner so unique, it’s unpredictable – comical scenes of subtle service, mech fighting, and romance. ... read more
  • InuBoku SS Moe Promotional Artwork
    To promote an upcoming live event, an amusing visual has been released on the official site of InuBoku SS – showing the crew of supernatural characters in a pop idol format, flashy colors and all, complete with effects. ... read more

About | Random | Donate | Etiquette | Contact

All Anime Everything.